Quoting within $(command substitution) in Bash

In order from worst to best:

    DIRNAME="$(dirname $FILE)" will not do what you want if $FILE contains whitespace or globbing characters \[?*.
    DIRNAME=`dirname "$FILE"` is technically correct, but backticks are not recommended for command expansion because of the extra quoting issues when nesting them.
    DIRNAME=$(dirname "$FILE") is correct, but only because this is an assignment. If you use the command substitution in any other context, such as export DIRNAME=$(dirname "$FILE") or du $(dirname "$FILE"), the lack of quotes will cause trouble if the result of the expansion contain whitespace or globbing characters.
    DIRNAME="$(dirname "$FILE")" is the recommended way. You can replace DIRNAME= with a command and a space without changing anything else, and dirname receives the correct string.

To improve even further:

    DIRNAME="$(dirname -- "$FILE")" works if $FILE starts with a dash.
    DIRNAME="$(dirname -- "$FILE"; printf x)" && DIRNAME="${DIRNAME%?x}" works even if $FILE ends with a newline, since $() chops off newlines at the end of output and dirname outputs a newline after the result.

You can nest command expansions as much as you like. With $() you always create a new quoting context, so you can do things like this:

foo "$(bar "$(baz "$(ban "bla")")")"

You do not want to try that with backticks.

In order from worst to best:

DIRNAME="$(dirname $FILE)" will not do what you want if $FILE contains whitespace or globbing characters \[?*.
    DIRNAME=`dirname "$FILE"` is technically correct, but backticks are not recommended for command expansion because of the extra quoting issues when nesting them.
    DIRNAME=$(dirname "$FILE") is correct, but only because this is an assignment. If you use the command substitution in any other context, such as export DIRNAME=$(dirname "$FILE") or du $(dirname "$FILE"), the lack of quotes will cause trouble if the result of the expansion contain whitespace or globbing characters.
    DIRNAME="$(dirname "$FILE")" is the recommended way. You can replace DIRNAME= with a command and a space without changing anything else, and dirname receives the correct string.

To improve even further:

DIRNAME="$(dirname -- "$FILE")" works if $FILE starts with a dash.
    DIRNAME="$(dirname -- "$FILE"; printf x)" && DIRNAME="${DIRNAME%?x}" works even if $FILE ends with a newline, since $() chops off newlines at the end of output and dirname outputs a newline after the result.

You can nest command expansions as much as you like. With $() you always create a new quoting context, so you can do things like this:

foo "$(bar "$(baz "$(ban "bla")")")"

You do not want to try that with backticks.

comments powered by Disqus

Title	Time
asdbfvb sdfnb adsdbv asdf	2 hours
sdgsdgsdgsdgsd	2 hours
afsgdfgcvxcbvbdfsdgfgadsf...	3 hours
sdgdgsdgd	4 hours
sdgdsgdsgsdg	5 hours
adfsgdfndaasfgdhfgh	5 hours
asrtfsdgdbdfgbdfh	7 hours

Paste4BTC

Raw paste:

Recent pastes